ZEFRANK.COM - message board  

Go Back   ZEFRANK.COM - message board > CURRENT EVENTS
FAQ Members List Calendar Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

 
 
Thread Tools Rating: Thread Rating: 17 votes, 5.00 average. Display Modes
Old 09-17-2005, 06:15 PM   #1
Hermione
monkey
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 3,060
Face Transplant

Doctor Pushes for First Face Transplant


CLEVELAND - In the next few weeks, five men and seven women will secretly visit the Cleveland Clinic to interview for the chance to have a radical operation that's never been tried anywhere in the world.


They will smile, raise their eyebrows, close their eyes, open their mouths. Dr. Maria Siemionow will study their cheekbones, lips and noses. She will ask what they hope to gain and what they most fear.

Then she will ask, "Are you afraid that you will look like another person?"

Because whoever she chooses will endure the ultimate identity crisis.

Siemionow wants to attempt a face transplant.

This is no extreme TV makeover. It is a medical frontier being explored by a doctor who wants the public to understand what she is trying to do.

It is this: to give people horribly disfigured by burns, accidents or other tragedies a chance at a new life. Today's best treatments still leave many of them with freakish, scar-tissue masks that don't look or move like natural skin.

These people already have lost the sense of identity that is linked to the face; the transplant is merely "taking a skin envelope" and slipping their identity inside, Siemionow contends.

Her supporters note her experience, careful planning, the team of experts assembled to help her, and the practice she has done on animals and dozens of cadavers to perfect the technique.

But her critics say the operation is way too risky for something that is not a matter of life or death, as organ transplants are. They paint the frighteningly surreal image of a worst-case scenario: a transplanted face being rejected and sloughing away, leaving the patient worse off than before.

Such qualms recently scuttled face transplant plans in France and England.

Ultimately, it comes to this: a hospital, doctor and patient willing to try it.

The first two are now in place. The third is expected to be shortly.

The "consent form" says that this surgery is so novel and its risks so unknown that doctors don't think informed consent is even possible.

Here is what it tells potential patients:

Your face will be removed and replaced with one donated from a cadaver, matched for tissue type, age, sex and skin color. Surgery should last 8 to 10 hours; the hospital stay, 10 to 14 days.

Complications could include infections that turn your new face black and require a second transplant or reconstruction with skin grafts. Drugs to prevent rejection will be needed lifelong, and they raise the risk of kidney damage and cancer.

After the transplant you might feel remorse, disappointment, or grief or guilt toward the donor. The clinic will try to shield your identity, but the press likely will discover it.

The clinic will cover costs for the first patient; nothing about others has been decided.

Another form tells donor families that the person receiving the face will not resemble their dead loved one. The recipient should look similar to how he or she did before the injury because the new skin goes on existing bone and muscle, which give a face its shape.

All of the little things that make up facial expression — mannerisms like winking when telling a joke or blushing at a compliment — are hard-wired into the brain and personality, not embedded in the skin.

Some research suggests the end result would be a combination of the two appearances.

Surgeons will graft skin to cover the donor's wound, but a closed casket or cremation will be required.

It took more than a year to win approval from the 13-member Institutional Review Board, the clinic's gatekeeper of research. Siemionow assembled surgeons, psychiatrists, social workers, therapists, nurses and patient advocates, and worked with LifeBanc, the organ procurement agency she expects will help obtain a face.

At first, not everyone was on her side, acknowledged the board's vice chairman, Dr. Alan Lichtin. After months of debate, Siemionow brought in photographs of potential patients.

Looking at the contorted images, Lichtin said he was struck by "the failure of the present state of the art to help these people." He decided he didn't want to deprive the surgeon or patients of the chance.

The board's decision didn't have to be unanimous.

In the end, it was.

Surgeons wished they could have done a transplant six years ago, when a 2-year-old boy attacked by a pit bull dog was brought to the University of Texas in Dallas where Dr. Karol Gutowski was training.

Other doctors had tried to reattach part of the boy's mauled face but it didn't take. The Texas surgeons did five skin grafts in a bloody, 28-hour surgery. Muscles from the boy's thigh were moved to around his mouth. Part of his abdomen became the lower part of his face. Two forearm sections became lips and mouth.

"He'll never be normal," said Gutowski, now a reconstructive surgeon at the University of Wisconsin-Madison.

Surviving such wounds can be "life by 1,000 cuts." Patients endure dozens of operations to graft skin inch by inch from their backs, arms, buttocks and legs. Only small amounts can be taken at a time because of bleeding.

Surgeons often return to the same areas every few weeks, reopening old wounds and building up skin. Years later, many patients are still having surgeries. A face transplant — applying a sheet of skin in one operation — could be a better solution.

Despite its shock factor, it involves routine microsurgery. One or two pairs of veins and arteries on either side of the face would be connected from the donor tissue to the recipient. About 20 nerve endings would be stitched together to try to restore sensation and movement. Tiny sutures would anchor the new tissue to the recipient's scalp and neck, and areas around the eyes, nose and mouth.

"For 10 years now, it could have been done," said Dr. John Barker, director of plastic surgery research at the University of Louisville, where the first hand transplant in the United States was performed in 1999.

Several years ago, these doctors announced their intent to do face transplants, but no hospital has yet agreed. They also are working with doctors in the Netherlands; nothing is imminent.

However, Siemionow had been doing experimental groundwork. She already had creatures that resembled raccoons in reverse — white rats with masks of dark fur — from years of face transplant experiments. She developed a plan and got clinic approval before going public, and insists she is not competing to do the first case.

"I hope nobody will be frivolous or do things just for fame. We are almost over-cautious," she said.

Siemionow, 55, went to medical school in Poland, trained in Europe and the United States, and has done thousands of surgeries in nearly 30 years. The success of this one depends on picking the right patient.

She wants a clear-cut first case. No children because risks are too great. No cancer patients because anti-rejection drugs raise the risk of recurrence.

"You want to choose patients who are really disfigured, not someone who has a little scar," yet with enough healthy skin for traditional grafts if the transplant fails, she said.

The person must bond with the transplant team, especially Siemionow. How much would she want to know about the person?

"Everything possible. It's a commitment on both sides," she said.

Dr. Joseph Locala will decide whether candidates are mentally fit. His chief concern: making sure they realize the risks.

"They almost need to understand as much as the surgeon," he said.
Hermione is offline  
Old 09-17-2005, 06:16 PM   #2
Hermione
monkey
 
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 3,060
there is more

A psychiatrist who has worked with transplant patients for 11 years, Locala knows they often have been coached on what to say to be chosen. He'd veto candidates who had abused alcohol or drugs, because they may not comply with medications.

Likewise someone who had attempted or seriously threatened suicide, or with little family or friends for support.

"I'm looking for a psychologically strong person. We want people who are going to make it through," he explained.

Dr. James Zins, chairman of plastic surgery, expects to be among the 10 to 12 doctors involved in the transplant and has been screening patients.

"We get some pretty strange calls from people who are really not candidates," he said. For someone to be chosen, "they're going to have to get a pass from every member of the team."

Matthew Teffeteller might seem an ideal candidate.

Hair is driving him crazy. What used to be a beard can't grow through the skin-graft quilt that Vanderbilt University doctors stitched over parts of his face that were seared off in a car crash. Trapped under this crust, hair festers, leading to staph infections, pain and more surgeries.

"It's a nightmare and it never ends," he said. "Being burned is the worst thing that can happen to you. I'm about sure of it."

Teffeteller, 26, lives south of Knoxville, in the foothills of Great Smoky Mountains National Park where he worked, ironically, as a fire fighter. The day after Valentine's Day in 2002, he was taking his pregnant wife to buy a cowboy hat and go country line dancing to celebrate their first anniversary.

"The next thing I remember, everything just went all to pieces...there was a big explosion. I remember seeing gas splash off of the windshield," he said.

Rear-ended by a truck, his car flipped and caught on fire. His wife died. He was burned trying to free her.

"They said my face was charcoal black," he said.

He didn't see it for two months, until he glimpsed a mirror on his way to therapy.

"Oh, my God," he thought. "I remember seeing my eyes pulled open. I remember my ears were burned off, and I remember my bottom lip being pulled down."

Three years later, his face still frightens children. Yet he wouldn't try a transplant.

"Having somebody else's face ... that wouldn't be right. When I look in the mirror, I might be scarred but I can still tell that it's me," he said.

"I'd be afraid something would go wrong, too. What would you do if you didn't have a face? Could you live?"

Bioethicist Carson Strong at the University of Tennessee wonders, too.

"It would leave the patient with an extensive facial wound with potentially serious physical and psychological consequences," he wrote last summer in the American Journal of Bioethics.

Such worries led the Royal College of Surgeons in England and the French National Ethics Advisory Committee to decide it shouldn't be tried. Any doctor considering it should examine soul and conscience, Strong wrote.

Ironically, people most emotionally devastated by disfigurement are those most likely to seek a transplant and least able to cope with uncertain results, media attention and loss of privacy, ethicists from England wrote in the same journal.

One worried that a donor family might have unhealthy expectations of seeing a loved-one "live on" in another person's body, or that recipients might want to see and approve a potential face.

No way, said Siemionow.

"It's not a shopping mall. They need to rely on our judgment. If they are starting to shop, they are not good candidates," she said.

Siemionow said critics should admit that risks and need for the transplant are debatable.

"Really, who has the right to decide about the patient's quality of life?" she asked. "It's very important not to kind of scare society.... We will do our best to help the patient."

If all of the candidates back out, "that's OK. It means that we are not ready yet," she said.

But if a transplant succeeds, many people who live in misery could benefit, said Gutowski, the Wisconsin surgeon.

"Someone's got to push the envelope," he said. "In retrospect, we'll know whether it should be done."
Hermione is offline  
Old 09-17-2005, 07:24 PM   #3
jasmina
Registered User
 
jasmina's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,619
God that's amazing.... ethically I'm not really sure what I think but if it helps people then you can't really be against it...
Wouldn't like to be a member of the donor family though.

(obviously this reminded me of face/off which was ridiculous!! Great film though!)
jasmina is offline  
Old 09-17-2005, 11:40 PM   #4
AllegroNg
What I Am Wearing.
 
AllegroNg's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: Near DC
Posts: 2,573

Last edited by AllegroNg : 09-19-2005 at 01:28 PM. Reason: It was a stupid thing to say
AllegroNg is offline  
Old 09-18-2005, 02:16 AM   #5
lapietra
half baked
 
lapietra's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: just ducky
Posts: 12,078
God - that was hard to read (painful - especially the part about skin from different parts of people's bodies being grafted to their face) but I'm sure it's ten times as hard to go through... I hope she's successful. It is incredibly difficult to have a good life in a world where so much rides on how attractive you are - if she can give them at least a normal appearance it will be a beautiful miracle.
__________________
“As long as the world is turning and spinning, we're gonna be dizzy and we're gonna make mistakes.” ~ Mel Brooks
lapietra is offline  
Old 09-18-2005, 12:38 PM   #6
Sapphire
Hippy Chick
 
Sapphire's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2005
Location: Southeast crease of the mitten
Posts: 92
This is amazing. I hope she is successful - what a life-altering miracle this could be for so many. I would gladly donate my face when I die if it would help someone. But then, I feel the same way about my entire body - it's all going to science/medicine - whatever they can use. I certainly won't need it!
__________________
Thou art God. Do you grok?
Sapphire is offline  
Old 09-18-2005, 03:34 PM   #7
trisherina
meretricious dilettante
 
trisherina's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 11,068
I feel the same way, Sapphire, but it's always good to check this one out with your loved ones -- you may have already, but a lot of people don't discuss this issue specifically and then problems arise when death is sudden. My spouse can't bear the thought of a med student snickering over or handling my cadaver in a rough fashion, even after I'm not in it anymore. So my personal directive allows only for the use of organs, not the whole enchilada, in deference to his concerns.
__________________
Because how we spend our days is, of course, how we spend our lives. -- Annie Dillard
trisherina is offline  
Old 09-18-2005, 09:18 PM   #8
Brynn
constantly amazed
 
Brynn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: in the labyrinth of shared happiness
Posts: 6,206
I read this cringing all the way, but am left feeling awe and admiration for the people who have to deal with their horrible scars every day.
It's hard to even imagine what I would do in their place - I mean, I like my face, you know - I really relate to the guy who essentially said "I may be disfigured, but at least I can still tell it's me in there."

It would be miraculous for burn/accident victims if this is successful, but I worry too for those brave/desperate first volunteers. This kind of transplant raises such interesting issues of identity. How much of how I see myself is tied up in my face? How much of my emotional survival depends on it?
Brynn is offline  
Old 01-10-2006, 07:11 AM   #9
Nevaeh96734
Registered User
 
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 5
Rationalization

Quote:
Originally Posted by jasmina

(obviously this reminded me of face/off which was ridiculous!! Great film though!).
Now I understand what you meant by "obviously". Thanks.





online casino directory - flash gambling
Nevaeh96734 is offline  
Old 01-10-2006, 03:40 PM   #10
ambo
feline, naturally
 
ambo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: California
Posts: 4,407
__________________
Non-violence leads to the highest ethics, which is the goal of all evolution. Until we have not stopped to include violence as an option in our conflict management, we are still savages.
--Thomas A. Edison
ambo is offline  
Old 01-10-2006, 09:25 PM   #11
zenbabe
Lollypop!
 
zenbabe's Avatar
 
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: we are all made of stars
Posts: 11,690
^^^ um???
__________________
Be yourself, because the people that mind don't matter, and the people that matter don't mind.

-Dr. Seuss
zenbabe is offline  
Old 01-15-2006, 09:19 PM   #12
Brynn
constantly amazed
 
Brynn's Avatar
 
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: in the labyrinth of shared happiness
Posts: 6,206
shopping for shoes = shopping for faces (?)
__________________
1. While sitting at your desk, lift your right foot off the floor and make clockwise circles.
2. Now, while doing this, draw the number "6" in the air with your right hand.
3. Your foot will change direction.
Brynn is offline  
Old 01-15-2006, 11:06 PM   #13
ambo
feline, naturally
 
ambo's Avatar
 
Join Date: Apr 2003
Location: California
Posts: 4,407
Sorry to be so obscure.
I was referring to the post above mine, which accompanied by the 3 others made on this board at the same time, seems fairly transparent.

Carry on.
__________________
Non-violence leads to the highest ethics, which is the goal of all evolution. Until we have not stopped to include violence as an option in our conflict management, we are still savages.
--Thomas A. Edison
ambo is offline  
Old 06-15-2006, 12:41 AM   #14
l'azizza
98.4% monkey
 
l'azizza's Avatar
 
Join Date: Dec 2005
Location: bummed out city
Posts: 634
man I seen some ugly ppl and I dont think they should go for the botox or acid rub- I think they should go for the entire face transplant
l'azizza is offline  
Old 07-09-2006, 01:10 AM   #15
TruthSeeker
monkey
 
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 68
I’m only briefly familiar with this. I saw some pictures of the lady from France who had the Face transplant. I thought she looked really good considering what she must’ve gone through. I also read that her lower lip was not functioning due to the nerve not being there..You have to admire someone willing to go through this procedure, and then be paraded in the media.

I wonder how the funerals are handled for the donor. I know in some cases they would opt for non-traditional services, but if the family wanted one, would they try to reconstruct the face somehow for the family?
TruthSeeker is offline  
 


Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:

Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

vB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is On
Forum Jump


All times are GMT -3. The time now is 08:47 PM.


Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.5
Copyright ©2000 - 2021, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.